ARCH shelter among Austin’s ‘greatest failures’ in addressing homelessness, downtown leader says


Several community leaders criticized Austin’s response to the growing homeless population during a public safety discussion this week, blaming much of the issue on a lack of adequate services.

Bill Brice, vice president of the Downtown Austin Alliance, said the city has continually fallen short in addressing the issue. He specifically called out the Austin Resource Center for the Homeless, or the ARCH, for its inadequacy.

“The ARCH represents one of the greatest failures of our community to address this problem,” Brice told the Public Safety Commission on June 5. “Who would want homeless services in their community when in everyone’s mind’s eye they see what lies outside the ARCH every single day?”

In January, the Ending Community Homelessness Coalition, or ECHO, counted 2,147 homeless people on the street. Austin Police Department Assistant Chief Justin Newsom said between 2,000 and 9,000 people experience homelessness in Austin each year.

Despite the large numbers and the year-to-year homeless population increase, the city has not expanded from the ARCH, which has roughly 100 beds available per night.

“In a city of a million people, we need more places for people to be,” Newsom said. “There is always going to be a need for the most sick, the most troubled to have help and services. What we give them is totally insufficient.”

Potential changes

Austin City Council is expected to re-examine three local laws that some say target the homeless population. They include a ban on aggressive solicitation, camping in the public right of way and sitting or laying down in certain parts of the community.

Emily Gerrick from the Texas Fair Defense Project said the ordinances not only target homeless people but are over-enforced and make it tougher for the cited individual to exit homelessness. She said the citations typically come with a fine they cannot pay or a court date their situation makes them likely to miss. Gerrick said the missed court date turns into an arrest warrant, which shows up on background checks for jobs and housing.

Gerrick said some courts have determined similar laws to violate the First Amendment—free speech—and the Eighth Amendment—mandating fair administration of justice.

Chris Harris with Grassroots Leadership agreed with the notion that the city substantially lacks services; however, he said the police department’s enforcement of “ineffective” ordinances drain city resources that could be put toward solutions.

Newsom said the ordinances allow the police department to issue lower class misdemeanors in substitute of a harsher charge. The no camping ordinance keeps police officers from in some instances issuing a criminal trespass charge, he said, and the aggressive solicitation ordinance allows officers to intervene before an assault happens.

Newsom said until the city builds somewhere for homeless people to go, the ordinances are necessary for public order.

“Without [the ordinances], you could have both sides of Congress Avenue—from the river to the Capitol—lined with tents, and all we can do is walk around them because there is no law that says they can’t be there,” Newsom said.

The Public Safety Commission passed a resolution encouraging the City Council to investigate improvements to how the city deals with homelessness. On June 14, the council will discuss a resolution that asks the city manager to develop a project and funding plan to address homelessness and housing initiatives.

Share this story
  1. More like “Chronic homelessness is among capitalism’s greatest, of many, failures”

  2. As an avid supporter of helping the less fortunate and a civil volunteer, I really question the competency of any city leader who believes maintaining a homeless shelter one block from where the most alcohol and drugs are consumed per sq/mile in all of Texas is a brilliant idea that will put these people on a path to recovery.

    In my humble opinion, The City of Austin should auction the land and use the funds to establish a real rehabilitation center outside of the core (but near public transportation) with more beds and mental health programs staffed by qualified professionals. If only our city council had a spine and the courage to do what is right…

    • Downtown Woman

      I agree with the above comment. It makes no sense to have an entire homeless community one block from the most frequented bars and restaurants. I am also very nervous about how this impacts public safety and the businesses downtown. I just walked 6 blocks from a parking lot to my downtown office in broad daylight and was spoken to by at least 10 different homeless men, sometimes aggressively. My other female coworkers have told me they have been sworn at during their morning walks. I don’t want to go downtown anymore. I don’t want to go to the restaurants downtown. I certainly don’t want to be walking anywhere near the homeless shelter. This is coming from someone who genuinely wants to see them helped, not someone who blames them for their situation…downtown feels like a city encouraging transient or homeless people. I don’t feel safe downtown.

  3. The only thing the city of Austin has done for the homeless is be their biggest enablers. Sell The Arch and built a facility for them to get help. I am the first to give and support a true homeless person, but these days I am only yelled out for offering food, instead of cash and being harassed on a daily basis. DO SOMETHING! So far your answer is do do absolutely nothing for the citizens of Austin and the homeless. And I give the volunteers credit for going out and trying to count the homeless, but I assure you those numbers are WAAAAAAAAY off. I can easily count 500 in one very small area in South Austin.

Christopher Neely
Christopher Neely is Community Impact's Austin City Hall reporter. A New Jersey native, Christopher moved to Austin in 2016 following two years of community reporting along the Jersey Shore. His bylines have appeared in the Los Angeles Times, Baltimore Sun and USA Today. He is a graduate of the University of Maryland's Philip Merrill College of Journalism.
Back to top