Austin area nursing shortage builds as pandemic persists

Photo of nurses holding hands with bowed heads
Registered nurses for a local Baylor Scott & White Health hospital participated in a moment of silence Sept. 3 to recognize a year and six month since the first Texas COVID-19 case. (Courtesy Baylor Scott & White Health)

Registered nurses for a local Baylor Scott & White Health hospital participated in a moment of silence Sept. 3 to recognize a year and six month since the first Texas COVID-19 case. (Courtesy Baylor Scott & White Health)

On Sept. 3, nurses in Austin’s three major hospital systems paused for a moment of silence to observe one year and six months since the first COVID-19 case was reported in the state.

By then, Austin was in the midst of its third catastrophic coronavirus surge. Hospitals in Austin’s 11-county trauma service region had treated more than 134,000 coronavirus patients, and Travis County was within a week of recording 1,000 deaths from the virus.

“[Our workers] honored those affected by COVID-19. ... For many, that includes family and friends,” Baylor Scott & White Health, St. David’s HealthCare and Ascension Seton said in a joint statement. “Health care workers have shown incredible courage and resiliency. Today was a time to honor their continued work.”

But after 18 months of pandemic conditions, the ranks of those workers were smaller—especially among nurses.

The three hospital systems said in July that a pre-existing nursing shortage had worsened as the delta variant sent patients in droves to the hospital. The surge has continued through September, and short staffing continues to restrict the capacity of already packed intensive care units.

According to Texas Workforce Solutions, there were 5,172 help wanted ads for registered nurses posted in the Capital Area in the second quarter of 2021. The open positions equal almost half of the 10,200 registered nurses who worked in the area in that time frame.

Cindy Zolnierek, CEO of the Texas Nurses Association, said the nursing shortage is longstanding and complex with roots in compensation disputes and insufficient resources in nursing education programs—but 18 months of high-stress work has brought the crisis to a fever pitch.

“Frankly, I am very concerned about the nursing workforce,” Zolnierek told Community Impact Newspaper. “There are nurses who are going to weather it through this crisis, but then they’ll say, ‘I’m done.’ What that will mean—at the same time as we’re struggling bringing new nurses in for a number of reasons—is it’s going to be a very challenging time moving forward.”

Staving off burnout

Since July, the number of available, staffed ICU beds in Austin has fluctuated between zero and five, according to Austin Public Health. While hospitals may postpone some elective procedures when capacity is so limited, they do not begin turning away patients with necessary care needs as soon as ICU capacity reaches zero, Austin hospital systems representatives say. However, they may have to ask staff to take on more work, including tasks not normally in their job description.

“All three health care systems are sourcing staff using multiple resources, increasing shifts, paying critical staffing bonuses and redeploying non-nursing staff to assist with non-clinical tasks,” the hospitals told Community Impact Newspaper in a joint statement.

In these circumstances, nurses are made responsible for more patients, said Jenna Laine, a nurse practitioner and a professor for Austin Community College’s mobility nursing program, an accelerated program for students with some pre-existing nursing experience.

“Most places I’ve worked, an ICU nurse takes on one to two patients,” Laine said. “There might be places [now] that might be trying to have an ICU nurse work for three patients, and that’s just way too much, because we’re talking about patients that need to be checked on every five to 15 minutes.”

Many nurses are also being scheduled to work back-to-back shifts, often while caring for patients facing grim outcomes, Zolnierek said.

“Folks are just exhausted,” she said. “There comes a point where [COVID-19 patients’] chances of survival are very, very low, so nurses are seeing a very high incidence of death. And that makes the work very difficult, because in some ways, it feels hopeless.”

Competing for talent

As pandemic-related burnout causes many nurses to leave the field, those who remain have options. Many have accepted higher-paying offers from travel nursing agencies supplying staff to overburdened hospitals, Zolnierek and other experts said.

Selena Xie, a surgical ICU nurse for Dell Seton Medical Center and President of the Austin EMS Association, said the pandemic “decimated our ranks,” and estimated that around 50% of her colleagues who have resigned accepted jobs as travel nurses.

“Wherever COVID[-19] is hardest hit, they’re offering them really big bonuses to go and work there for like two months,” Xie said.

This summer and fall, Texas has been one of those hardest-hit areas. Gov. Greg Abbott announced Aug. 19 that he would contract with staffing agencies to deploy supplemental staff to hospitals across the state. To avoid Texas nurses leaving their current positions in favor of more lucrative traveling contracts—a phenomenon that was common earlier in the pandemic, Zolnierek said—Abbott required the state-funded supplemental staff to come from outside of Texas, as seen in job postings from state-contracted staffing agencies such as Krucial Staffing.

Nurses deployed to Texas with Krucial earn a base salary of $125 an hour, outstripping the median pay for RNs in the Austin-Round Rock area, which sits under $35 an hour, according to the Texas Workforce Commission.

Travel nursing positions in other states, including Florida, remain plentiful. In order to compete, all of Austin’s major hospital systems currently offer bonuses to new ICU nursing hires. However, to retain nurses in the long run, Xie said Austin employers need to match the pay scale present in other Texas cities: Dallas RNs make nearly $37 an hour, and Houston nurses make around $40 hourly.

“Even before the pandemic, we would have a lot of people leave for Houston or Dallas,” she said.

Education bottleneck

Also contributing to Austin’s nursing shortage is a lack of supply at the entry level. Local registered nursing programs have a waiting list of qualified applicants every year, but lack the space, faculty and resources to accommodate them, said Leigh Goldstein, a nursing professor at the University of Texas at Austin.

“I believe there are a lot of people who would go to nursing school if they had the opportunity to get in,” Goldstein told Community Impact Newspaper. “[It] really puts a chokehold on things if you don’t have enough faculty.”

As of 2019, only 1.2% of Texas nurses were qualified to teach, holding a doctoral-level degree in nursing. However, nurses in that pool often choose to work as a nurse practitioner—typically a better paying role, Zolnierek said.

Austin also has limited clinical space to share among nursing programs, Goldstein said, which in Travis County include Austin Community College, UT, Concordia University Texas and others.

Over the past two decades, Texas has sought to increase the number of nurses in the state through its Nursing Shortage Reduction Program, which provides grants to nursing education programs to help boost enrollment and graduation rates. Since its inception the program has succeeded in growing the nursing workforce; the number of active RNs has grown by nearly 43% since 2010 from 176,251 to 251,253.

Yet supply remains below demand. Throughout Central Texas, the Texas Department of State Health Services projects 31,608 RN positions are needed in 2021, with 26,935 nurses available, a shortfall of 14.8%.

Graduates step up

For students graduating from nursing programs this year, pandemic conditions are an expected reality. Amarachi Amaikwu, a 2021 graduate of ACC’s RN program, will soon to begin work for St. David’s HealthCare in October. She began her program in August 2020 with COVID-19 in full swing, taking most classes online. She and her classmates called their experience “pandemic university.”

“I definitely empathize with those who have left the field,” Amaikwu said. “However, I’m excited to jump in and help where I can as the pandemic continues.”

Nursing faculty have also adjusted their instruction over the past year and a half to prepare students for the environment they will enter, Goldstein said. That includes teaching students how to handle personal protective equipment in high-risk situations as well as the importance of practicing self care to avoid burnout.

However, with hospitals still strapped for staff, one nursing student said she is bracing for exhaustion.

“I’ve kind of mentally prepared myself to know that I may have moments where I’m like, ‘This is really a lot. What am I going to do?’” said Camille Batts, a UT nursing student who will graduate in December. “Nothing’s really going to prepare us for truly going into the pandemic.”
By Olivia Aldridge

Reporter, Central Austin

Olivia joined Community Impact Newspaper as a reporter in March 2019. She covers public health, business, development and Travis County government. A graduate of Presbyterian College in South Carolina, Olivia worked as a reporter and producer for South Carolina Public Radio before moving to Texas. Her work has appeared on NPR and in the New York Times.


The second segment of the trail was split into two parts due to flood plain issues. The first part is expected to wrap up by the end of 2022.  (Courtesy Austin Public Works Department)
Austin begins work on second section of Northern Walnut Creek Trail

The city aims to have another 1.3 miles of the 19-mile trail complete by the end of 2022.

The Park and Recreation Board voted twice to deny a request to allow beer and wine to be sold in the area around Zilker Cafe. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin Planning Commission turns down plan to sell beer, wine at Zilker Cafe

Eight commissioners voted in favor to deny the applicants request while two voted against the motion. Commissioner Awais Azhar abstained from voting.

Photo of Austin's skyline
Austin health authorities outline COVID-19 surge risks while eyeing possible shift to Stage 2

While Austin and Travis County remain under Stage 3 guidelines, hospitalizations have moved into possible Stage 2 territory.

Giselle Copa, an Austin Community College pharmacy student, prepares a COVID-19 vaccine for administration. (Community Impact Newspaper staff)
At least 81% of Austin ISD staff are fully vaccinated against COVID-19, per district data

After the district had staff sign up for bonuses only available to fully vaccinated employees, the district can count its vaccinated employees at over 8,000.

"The Dude" is the signature burger at Lebowski's Grill. (Olivia Aldridge/Community Impact Newspaper)
CI NATION ROUNDUP: Lebowski's Grill upends expectations in Austin; first Houston-area Costco Business Center opens in Stafford and more top news

Take a look at the top five trending stories across all of Community Impact Newspaper’s coverage areas as of Oct. 26.

More than 35,000 passengers traveled through the airport on Oct. 25, the Monday following the 2021 F1 U.S. Grand Prix. (Benton Graham/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin-Bergstrom International Airport sees busiest day ever following 2021 Formula One U.S. Grand Prix

The new record topped the previous busiest day by more than 3,000 passengers.

City, county and community leaders gathered Oct. 21 to share an update on funding of the $515 million Summit Plan aimed at housing thousands of residents. (Ben Thompson/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin leaders outline $515M homelessness spending plan with more than 75% of funding in place

Officials provided an update on a $515 million plan to house thousands of people experiencing homelessness and provide related social services Oct. 21.

The plan calls for traffic control methods to make streets safer for pedestrians and cyclists. (Courtesy Living Streets)
Austin City Council paves way for more play, exercise on neighborhood streets

The program aims to make it safer to use neighborhood streets for community events.

Photo of the Komé storefront
Komé Sushi Kitchen celebrates 10 years, and more Austin business milestones

The locally-owned business serves family-style Japanese comfort food.

New statewide maps will go into effect Jan. 18, 2022. (Community Impact Newspaper Staff)
Gov. Abbott approves new voting maps for state legislature, Congress, school districts for next decade

The maps will go into effect Jan. 18, 2022, after the state legislature passed them during a 30-day special session.

The committee will provide input on Capital Metro's expanded public safety department to the transit agency's board of directors.  (Courtesy Capital Metro)
Capital Metro board approves charter for public safety advisory committee

The approval comes after the establishment of a transit police force met resistance during the August meeting.