EXPLAINED: How will the proposed property tax bill affect Texas taxpayers?

Updated 9:02 a.m. March 15

Tuesday featured a lot of action in the Texas Legislature, including the first public hearing on Senate Bill 2, a proposal by state Sen. Paul Bettencourt, R-Houston, that aims to provide property tax relief and reform.

Early Wednesday morning, the Senate Finance Committee voted the bill out of committee in a 9-5 split with a significant amendment that partially changed the fabric of the bill. The amendment was offered by state Sen. Joan Huffman, R-Houston.

Those voting against the bill include Sen. Royce West, D-Dallas, Sen. Kel Seliger, R-Amarillo, Sen. Carlos Uresti, D-San Antonio, Sen. Kirk Watson, D-Austin, and Sen. Juan Hinojosa, D-McAllen.

Seliger was skeptical of the bill throughout the hearing because of its nature to preempt local decisions on property taxes.

The hearing has been full of data and jargon, so here are answers to the many questions brought about by this bill:

What does the bill do?

In its initial form, SB 2 would lower the rollback tax rate from its current cap of 8 percent to 4 percent. This would allow property taxes to increase by no more than 4 percent from year to year, unless a special election would be called. As it stands now, a rollback election would only be triggered when a tax rate exceeds 8 percent and would also require a petition to be signed for such an election.

However, Huffman's amendment changed the proposed 4 percent threshold to 5 percent, with the hope that this extra percentage point would still enable cities and political jurisdictions to carry out services for citizens.

"I think that the testimony that we heard today was very impactful, I think we heard from constituents from all over the state...I think that's a nice middle ground," Huffman said.

The bill's sponsor, Bettencourt, noted the rollback rate was capped at 5 percent in 1979, during a period of high inflation, but with a changing economy, the rate was raised to 8 percent.

In the amendment process, another member of the Finance Committee, state Sen. Kelly Hancock, R-North Richland Hills, noted that it was time to return the rollback rate to its original form.

The bill would also mandate that any city or jurisdiction that would raise the rate must hold an election on a general election date. The bill would also create a Property Tax Advisory Board under the Texas Comptroller.

Why did Bettencourt author the bill?

Bettencourt chaired the Senate Select Committee on Property Tax Reform and Relief over the interim session. He, along with the committee, visited seven cities and heard more than 50 hours of testimony on Texas' rising property taxes.

Bettencourt said property tax bills have increased by 36 percent within Harris County in the past three years. In addition, property tax appraisals have risen more than 22 percent in Dallas-Fort Worth, 20 percent in San Antonio and 12 percent in Austin over three years, according to Bettencourt.

Who supports the bill?

Bettencourt is joined by five other co-authors, all Republican senators. Members of the business community, including the Texas Building Owners and Managers Association and the Texas Association of Manufacturers.

At the public hearing, Catherine Morse, general counsel for Samsung Austin Semiconductor, said the company supports SB 2 because it would provide a business friendly environment. Morse said her company is the largest property taxpayer in Travis County and understands that without changes to property tax law, incentivizing big business to settle in Texas could be a challenge.

Here is a list of some of the interests who voiced support for the bill at the hearing:

  • Texas Taxpayers and Research Association

  • Samsung Austin Semiconductor

  • Austin City Council Member Ellen Troxclair (not indicative of city of Austin's opinion)

  • Cheryl Johnson, tax assessor-collector of Galveston County

  • Texas Building Owners and Managers Association

  • Texas Association of Manufacturers

  • Collin County


Who opposes the legislation?

Overall, cities and law enforcement have been largely against this kind of property tax reform. In November, the Texas Municipal League denounced Bettencourt's interim committee recommendations.

"The largest budget item for every city in Texas is public safety—police, fire fighting and emergency medical services,” said Bennett Sandlin, executive director of the Texas Municipal League.  “Politicians can’t proclaim their support for first responders and then turn around and vote to restrict the funding that pays for the salaries, equipment, vehicles, health insurance and pensions of the men and women who protect our communities."

Since the hearing started, the mayors of Dallas and Fort Worth have testified against the bill, saying it would not create the relief taxpayers truly want and that it would restrict the ability of cities to expand services alongside growing populations.

Sen. John Whitmire, D-Houston, echoed similar concerns, saying Bettencourt has not thought of how cities can cope with burgeoning populations.

"Why do you continue to attack local governments?" Whitmire said. "What would you tell them to do?"

Senators Joan Huffman, R-Houston, and Kel Seliger, R-Amarillo, have also raised concerns about superseding local control.

Here is a list of some of the interests who voiced opposition to the bill at the hearing:

  • The city of Dallas

  • The city of Fort Worth

  • San Antonio Police Department

  • The city of Frisco

  • The city of Grapevine

  • The city of Houston

  • The city of Denton

  • Texas Conference of Urban Counties

  • Center for Public Policy Priorities


What is next for the bill?

After the bill was voted out of committee, some Senate Finance Committee members indicated a further desire to work through additional amendments. The bill will face debate on the Senate floor, voting and if approved, the same process in the House.




Click here for more of Community Impact Newspaper's coverage on property tax relief.


MOST RECENT

The weekly market will debut with about 20 vendors on Oct. 16. (Courtesy Joshua Reed)
Weekly Montgomery Farmers Market to debut in mid-October in Ransom's Steakhouse parking lot

The farmers market will be an offshoot of the Sanctuary Blueberry Farm in Montgomery.

The Friends of Conroe Inc. will present the Conroe Cajun Catfish Festival on Oct. 8-10. (Courtesy Visit Conroe)
TO-DO: 13 fall events to attend in Conroe, Montgomery

Check out these 13 events this fall in Conroe and Montgomery, from a wine festival to holiday markets and historical commemorations.

Current Friendswood ISD protocols encourage community members to make their own choice regarding masking. (Courtesy Pexels)
Friendswood ISD leaders discuss revising COVID-19 protocols to encourage masking indoors

No changes were voted on at the Sept. 15 meeting. District leaders indicated they will not move toward language instituting a mask mandate due to potential legal complications.

Texas-wide public charter school system Harmony Public Schools will offer a full virtual learning option for eligible students. (Courtesy Harmony Public Schools)
Harmony Public Schools will offer virtual learning for K-12 students in Houston, Katy, Sugar Land, Cypress

Schools under the Harmony Public Schools umbrella may offer up to 10% of its student body a full virtual learning option.

The Texas Department of Transportation is planning to install medians along 5.8 miles of FM 1092 from Hwy. 59 to Hwy. 6 in Missouri City. (Courtesy Fotolia)
As FM 1092 median project goes out to bid, some Missouri City Council Members still object

Construction on the project to install medians on FM 1092—also known as Murphy Road—is expected to begin in the winter and last for seven months, according to officials with TxDOT.

The Cuban Flavor on Sept. 11 opened its restaurant in Friendswood.  (Courtesy The Cuban Flavor)
Authentic Cuban restaurant opens in Friendswood

The Cuban Flavor on Sept. 11 opened its restaurant in Friendswood.

Normal school operations will resume at Fort Bend ISD's Fort Settlement Middle School after power was restored to the campus. (Community Impact Newspaper staff)
UPDATE: Fort Bend ISD's Fort Settlement Middle School to reopen Sept. 17 following Hurricane Nicholas

Normal school operations will resume at Fort Bend ISD's Fort Settlement Middle School after power was restored to the campus.

The Fab 5, a Beatles tribute band, will be playing live music at Tomball's annual GroovFest on Sept. 18. (Photo courtesy Mike Baxter/City of Tomball)
Get groovy, attend a livestock show: 5 events in Tomball, Magnolia on Sept. 17-18

Both Magnolia ISD high schools will be playing home football games, and the district will be hosting a job fair this weekend.

Q&A: Get to know Bobby Warren, Jersey Village’s newest mayor

Bobby Warren was elected mayor of Jersey Village in May. Check out our Q&A to see what he's been up to and what his priorities are moving forward.

Lambeau's Sports Bar & Grill is now open. (Courtesy Lambeau's Sports Bar & Grill)
Lambeau’s Sports Bar & Grill holds soft opening on Louetta Road

During the soft opening, the eatery will offer full bar service and a limited version of its food menu.

At the Sept. 14 Harris County Commissioners Court meeting, County Administrator David Berry, top left, presents proposed tax rates to commissioners Jack Cagle and Tom Ramsey, Judge Lina Hidalgo, and commissioners Adrian Garcia and Rodney Ellis. (Emily Lincke/Community Impact Newspaper)
Harris County commissioners propose lower tax rates with split vote

While the proposed tax rate is lower than the current rate, tax payers may actually end up paying more since the values of homes statewide increased this year, according to County Administrator David Berry.

The business offers battery, lighting, smart home and key fob selections, and phone repair services. (Courtesy Batteries   Bulbs)
Batteries + Bulbs coming soon to Montgomery

The business offers battery, lighting, smart home and key fob selections, and phone repair services.