Q&A: Policy analyst weighs in on dynamic between state, local orders during the coronavirus

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton sent letters May 12 to officials in Dallas, Bexar and Travis counties as well as the cities of Austin and San Antonio, alleging that their local public health orders amid the coronavirus were “unlawful" and "unenforceable.”

The letters alleged that some elements of the local orders mandating Austin residents to stay home are illegal because they "exceed the city and county's lawful authority," Community Impact Newspaper reported.

Prior to Paxton’s letter, Gov. Greg Abbott called out Harris County at a press conference April 27, saying that the county could not issue fines or penalize residents for not wearing face masks. The attorney general’s office referred only to the May 12 release when Community Impact Newspaper asked Paxton’s office why Central Texas counties and municipalities received letters from the attorney general but Harris County did not.

Community Impact Newspaper spoke with Jonathan Lewis, senior policy analyst at the Center for Public Policy Priorities, an independent public policy association, on May 13 about the shifting dynamic between local and state power amid the crisis. This interview has been edited for length and clarity.

How have the state, counties and municipalities been handling the coronavirus pandemic?

Public health has always fallen very heavily on counties and cities, and the state has a fairly small public health expenditure. Counties do a lot of the heavy lifting. They're running county hospitals, ... so there’s already this dynamic in place where counties and cities are really the go-to on public health within their jurisdictions. It’s been interesting to see the governor originally talking about how local communities should decide; he left them pretty vague and was leaning a lot on counties and local communities to decide what's best for them. This latest order that talks about superseding local orders is really a pretty big shift in not only that historic duties of public health in the state but prior pandemic response.

What’s happening in Texas compared with other states across the nation as they, too, work their way through this pandemic? How are other states handling it differently or similarly?

This is definitely a trend we're seeing all across the country in red and blue states. I think it's just because of the unprecedented nature of [the pandemic]. There are obviously strong feelings about which approaches are necessary or appropriate or when and how much. I think everyone's just trying to figure this out as we go. It's definitely not exclusive to Texas.

What does this communication from Attorney General Ken Paxton mean for local counties and municipalities as they try to navigate reopening during the pandemic?

I think it's an interesting thing to think about when Texas has always been a home rule state, and so it's part of a continuing narrative of state leaders not trusting local officials to make decisions that are best for local communities. We saw a lot of efforts to really limit the power of cities last [legislative] session, and I think [recent decisions are] in line with those efforts. ... You would hope that the state would lean on the authorities that have provided this guidance on public health in the past. ... We think it's very important that there is a statewide coordination to address the pandemic and really implement some guidelines to help us understand what is needed in these times to help us get through this. The difference here in thinking is that the state [should] set a floor of some minimum requirements that need to be in place for the state as a whole, but still allow local health officials to decide and assess the needs in their community. ... We have already put it in a statute that this is a power that we believe [for] home rule municipalities. The governor’s order to supersede that authority that we’ve already given cities represents a pretty large shift in the power of local elected officials to do what is best for their communities.
By Kelly Schafler

Editor, Lake Houston | Humble | Kingwood

Kelly Schafler is the editor for the Lake Houston, Humble and Kingwood edition of Community Impact Newspaper, covering public education, city government, development, businesses, local events and all things community-related. Before she became editor, she was the reporter for the Conroe and Montgomery edition for a year and a half.


Texas Litter Control will also offer dog and cat adoptions at its new Humble clinic. (Courtesy Texas Litter Control)
Nonprofit organization Texas Litter Control opens new Humble clinic

It also provides adoption services, community education, and surgery training for high-volume spaying and neutering.

ExxonMobil moved employees from its Springwoods Village campus to a Hughes Landing to cure a default on a Montgomery County tax abatement. (Courtesy ExxonMobil)
ExxonMobil resolves tax abatement default; Home Depot distribution center taking over superfund site; and more top Houston-area news

Read the most popular business and community news from the past week from the Houston area.

The University of St. Thomas is a private Catholic college in Houston. It also has a microcampus in downtown Conroe. (Emma Whalen/Community Impact Newspaper)
University of St. Thomas offering free tuition to first 500 students who apply

The online degrees are in the following fields: cybersecurity, network technology, electronic technology, general business, and alcohol and drug dependency counseling.

houston firefighters rally
Appeals court rules in favor Houston firefighters in collective bargaining case

The 14th Court of Appeals ruled in favor of the fire union in a case that originated when the city and the union failed to reach an agreement on a labor contract in 2017.

The city of Humble has been investing in improvements to its four parks, such as Schott Park. (Kelly Schafler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Officials talk park improvements, incoming e-commerce tenant at Humble BizCom event

Local business leaders and community members gathered virtually May 6 at Humble BizCom event hosted by Partnership Lake Houston.

The Texas Department of State Health Services projects a significant shortage of nurses by 2032. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Q&A: Why Texas faces a growing nursing shortage and what can be done to address it

In 2018, the state health department estimated about 11% of the demand for nurses was not able to be met, and that number is expected to rise to 16.3% by 2032.

Legacy Community Health is bringing COVID-19 vaccines to historically underserved communities across Beaumont and Houston. (Courtesy Pexels)
Legacy Community Health vaccine rollout targets underserved communities in Houston, Beaumont

The health network is partnering with other entities, including Beaumont Independent School District.

Houston, Harris County annual addresses no longer hosted by Greater Houston Partnership over Texas voter bill dispute

Local leaders criticized the area chamber of commerce for not taking a definitive stance on two voting access bills currently being deliberated in the Texas Legislature.

The new location is Chipotle's first in Magnolia. (Courtesy Chipotle Mexican Grill)
Chipotle opens in Magnolia; get a sneak peek of new Houston aquarium and more metro news

Read the latest business and community news from the Houston area.

The business specializes in customized in-home consultations during which families will receive a fire safety plan specific to their house's floor plan and an age-appropriate, individualized plan for each family member. (Courtesy Fire Smart, LLC)
Fire Smart, LLC celebrates one year of providing fire safety education across Greater Houston area

The business specializes in customized in-home consultations during which families will receive a fire safety plan specific to their house's floor plan and an age-appropriate, individualized plan for each family member.

The Houston Interactive Aquarium & Animal Preserve's marine building has sharks, turtles, stingrays, alligators, fish and eels. (Kelly Schafler/Community Impact Newspaper)
UPDATED: Houston Interactive Aquarium & Animal Preserve opening delayed as attraction awaits final approval, inspections

The Houston Interactive Aquarium & Animal Preserve will open off Beltway 8 in the Humble area.