The city of Houston’s attorneys said a proposed ordinance that would codify Mayor John Whitmire’s executive order—to stop the Houston Police Department from contacting Immigration and Customs Enforcement during stops for non-jailable offenses—is unlawful.
What happened?
In early November, Whitmire announced an executive order that limits the HPD’s communication with ICE to jailable offenses. At the time, Whitmire said Gov.-elect Gina Hinojosa would not prioritize cooperation with ICE.
Outgoing Attorney General Ken Paxton sued the city over the order, but Whitmire said Attorney General-elect Nathan Johnson indicated his office would not pursue the lawsuit.
After the order, council members Alejandra Salinas, Edward Pollard and Tiffany Thomas used Prop A to propose making the order law in Houston. During the Nov. 18 meeting, city attorney Arturo Michel said that, as it is written, it is unlawful.
“[Senate Bill] 4 is still in effect,” he said. “An ordinance that says you do not have to comply with SB 4 is unlawful.”
SB 4, which passed in 2017, requires compliance with ICE detainment and bans sanctuary cities.
What they are saying
Whitmire said he took the risk by making the new rule an executive order, since the city did get sued. However, he posed a question to council members: “What’s broken? The policy is in place, and it’s working, so let’s go forward.”
Some council members said the ordinance is needed for future administrations, but Whitmire said he is the mayor now, and he is implementing the order.
However, Thomas, one of the bill’s co-sponsors, said she believes the proposed ordinance can become law because it mirrors the executive order.
“The question in my head is why it was so important to be law of the land when the administration presented an ordinance,” Thomas said. “Why was it important to vote as a body … but it’s not important to do it when we have the political wins?”
One more thing
Although the order is technically not a law, HPD is still complying with it, officials said.