Austin's use of credit cards by employees is out of line with other Texas cities and not closely monitored, a new internal audit report found, increasing potential risks of abuse and needless spending.
The big picture
Compared to some peer cities across the state, Austin is a significant outlier both in the number of individual credit cards it issues to employees and the total amount they spend per year.
Austin issued nearly 1,600 individual credit cards in fiscal year 2024-25, nearly double that of Houston, the city with the next-highest total. Around $45 million was spent in FY 2024-25 across those cards, several times more than Fort Worth's roughly $10 million spent. Even after averaging employees per card and spending per card, Austin still outpaced its Texas peers.
Direct comparisons to Houston and San Antonio's spending aren't available as Austin auditors couldn't collect that financial information. Local totals also don't include information from Austin Energy—which had an estimated 237 employee credit cards with roughly $10 million spent in FY 2024-25—due to the utility transitioning its card management systems during the audit.
City auditors said their study showed Austin is out of line with best practices related to credit card access, employee training and city monitoring, and found:
Credit card activity isn't closely reviewed to shut down underused cards.
Austin only requires one-time training on credit card use that is outdated and doesn't offer thorough guidance. Other cities also require refresher training annually or every 2 years.
Documentation of credit card purchases is often unclear, making it difficult to determine what was bought and why, and isn't frequently reviewed for cost efficiencies.
Additionally, auditors pointed to their office's investigations into multiple cases of employee spending abuses over recent years that stemmed from weak processes, including supervisory reviews. Stronger oversight to limit card access with regular training and monitoring could improve Austin's system, they reported.
“These investigations highlight the importance of following all best practices to prevent fraud and misuse," lead auditor Ashley Rodriguez said.
The approach
Auditors proposed several improvements related to Austin's credit card management and oversight. All were accepted by city management and expected to be completed within the current fiscal year 2026-27.
The audit recommended:
Reviewing and revoking cards deemed to be underutilized at least annually
Revising initial employee credit card training and requiring recurring annual trainings for all users
Updating policies to clarify purchasing and related documentation standards, require more levels of review, and regularly assess whether the monitoring system is working
Analyzing all credit card purchases on an annual basis for savings opportunities
Auditors said the changes could center Austin Financial Service's role related to credit card use, a shift from the current system that defers more to individual departments on spending needs and oversight.
City finance officials confirmed updates are now underway. City Council members asked for updates throughout implementation, and council member Marc Duchen suggested a follow-up report late next year to ensure those changes lead to the desired results.
Auditors and finance staff also noted the new report and related policy adjustments may not necessarily impact Austin's overall usage of credit cards, which they said can help reduce administrative burdens and costs. Purchasing official James Scarboro said the city has a $3,000 threshold for spending on the "small dollar, high volume transactions" that can lead to significant savings when handled properly.
"That’s kind of the value basis for having a purchasing card. But there’s a point of exceeding the benefit by having too many cards, using it too often, and you’re losing the opportunity for directing that to on-contract managed spend," he said. "That’s kind of the balance point I believe were addressed in the recommendation.”