Town: Council Member-elect Laurin Hendrix not entitled to attorney’s fees, cost

Judge's gavel
Laurin Hendrix has asked Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Daniel Kiley to award him more than $34,000 in attorney's fees and costs associated with his lawsuit against the town to be seated on council immediately. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)

Laurin Hendrix has asked Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Daniel Kiley to award him more than $34,000 in attorney's fees and costs associated with his lawsuit against the town to be seated on council immediately. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)

The town of Gilbert argues it should it not be held responsible for Town Council Member-elect Laurin Hendrix’s legal fees in a response filed Sept. 30 in Maricopa County Superior Court.

The town, through private attorney Charles Wirken of Gust Rosenfeld, argued that the laws Hendrix cites in asking for his attorney’s fee to be paid by the defendants do not apply, that he did not prevail in his lawsuit against the town and that the fees asked for were unreasonable.

Hendrix filed suit Aug. 18, seeking to be seated to Gilbert Town Council immediately upon the Aug. 4 election results being declared official. Though attorney Timothy La Sota, Hendrix argued that because Bill Spence, whom Hendrix defeated in the election, was appointed to council, Hendrix was entitled to take the seat immediately.

The town planned to seat Hendrix with other election winners on the second Tuesday of January.

Judge Daniel Kiley, citing state law, ruled Sept. 11 that Hendrix could take his seat on the date of the general election, Nov. 3. Hendrix has appealed that ruling. He also filed for attorney’s fees and costs of $34,447.50 be paid for by the town because he had prevailed in the case.


The town argued that Kiley’s ruling was essentially a “push”—that it did not fall with the town or Hendrix’s arguments on when Hendrix could be seated, but between the two positions. It also ruled that Hendrix lost in what else he asked for in relief—that council be prevented from making any decisions until he is seated. Kiley twice ruled against such requests.

In addressing the fees, the town noted that the affidavit detailing 79.7 hours of work at $425 per hour was incorrect in that it showed only 78.8 hours. It further argued that the amount of time spent in different areas and the hourly rate were unreasonable.

It also argues that some of the time was spent in litigation against Spence, who keeps separate counsel. Wirken represents the town and Town Clerk Lisa Maxwell. In his ruling on the suit, Kiley ruled that Spence is not an usurper of Hendrix’s seat.

In a statement sent by email Oct. 1, the town said the suit involves the legal interpretation of statutes and has acted legally in good faith defending the suit.

“As a general policy, the town does not pay the legal fees for individuals or entities who bring legal actions against it unless ordered to by a court,” the statement read. “It is the court’s role to determine whether there is a statutory basis for a fee request, and if so, whether the amount requested is reasonable.”

The hearing on Hendrix’s appeal is scheduled for Oct. 20.
By Tom Blodgett
Raised in Arizona, Tom Blodgett has spent 30 years in journalism in Arizona and is the editor of the Gilbert edition of Community Impact Newspaper. He is a graduate of Arizona State University, where he now serves as an instructional professional in the Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication and editorial adviser to The State Press, the university's independent student media outlet.


MOST RECENT

Photo from inside a movie theater
Alamo Drafthouse files for bankruptcy, closes theaters in downtown Austin and New Braunfels

Most theaters will remain open under an asset purchase agreement to the company's senior lending partners.

Jason Martin
Gilbert Public Schools considers closing Houston Elementary, moving Neely Traditional Academy

The Gilbert Public Schools governing board studied the effects of school changes for the fall that would close one school and move another into its campus.

Marcie Taylor
End-of-year celebrations getting face-lift in Gilbert Public Schools

Desert Ridge and Mesquite high schools, which have held their graduations at Arizona State University’s Wells Fargo Arena in previous years, will have to bring their ceremonies back to their campus stadiums, said Marcie Taylor, secondary education executive director.

Gilbert Public Schools district office
Finances good for now, but Gilbert Public Schools could see $10.22M reduction for next year

Gilbert Public Schools officials presented the governing board March 2 with a healthier revised budget for this fiscal year, but a projection for next year shows a large cut could be looming.

People age 55 and up will be eligible for COVID-19 vaccine appointments beginning at noon March 2. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Arizonans 55 and older will be eligible for vaccine appointments beginning March 2

People age 55 and up will be eligible for COVID-19 vaccine appointments beginning at noon March 2.

Cafe Rio Mexican Grill
One restaurant now open, one coming in Gilbert

Here are two restaurants open or coming to Gilbert.

See a breakdown of COVID-19 cases, vaccinations and more local data. (Community Impact staff)
COVID-19: Gilbert cases up 62 in two days March 2

See a breakdown of COVID-19 cases, vaccinations and more local data.

Here are the coronavirus hospitalization data updates to know across Arizona. (Community Impact staff)
ADHS: Less than 1,100 people hospitalized with COVID-19 symptoms March 3

Take a look at the hospitalization data across Arizona.

COVID-19 vaccine appointments are available at Chandler-Gilbert Community College. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
COVID-19 vaccination appointments available beginning March 1 at Chandler-Gilbert Community College

COVID-19 vaccination appointments will be available beginning at 9 a.m. March 1 at Chandler-Gilbert Community College—the latest state-run vaccination site.

Denise Lopez
Denise Lopez appointed HD South chief

Denise Lopez replaces Kayla Kolar, who left in 2020 to become the executive director of House of Refuge, as HD South's president and CEO.

The new Cracker Barrel Old Country Store location in Gilbert had standing waits outside when it opened its doors Feb. 15. (Tom Blodgett/Community Impact Newspaper)
Cracker Barrel open in Gilbert; Harbor Freight to open March 6 in Chandler and more February news

Read the latest business and community news from February in Gilbert and Chandler.

Western Canal
Gilbert officials wanted to avoid land acquisitions along Western Canal, staff tells residents

When Gilbert staff first addressed the problem of a deteriorating sewer along the Western Canal, they hoped to avoid using eminent domain to acquire land to fix the problem, staff told residents Feb. 25.