Judge rules Laurin Hendrix can join Gilbert Town Council on Nov. 3

judge's gavel
Laurin Hendrix will become a Gilbert Town Council member at the time of the general election Nov. 3 under Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Daniel Kiley's ruling on Hendrix's lawsuit against the town and Council Member Bill Spence. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)

Laurin Hendrix will become a Gilbert Town Council member at the time of the general election Nov. 3 under Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Daniel Kiley's ruling on Hendrix's lawsuit against the town and Council Member Bill Spence. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)

Gilbert Town Council Member-elect Laurin Hendrix may be seated to council Nov. 3, the date of the general election—not the immediate seating he sought, but earlier than the town set as his start date.

Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Daniel Kiley also ruled Sept. 11 that appointed Council Member Bill Spence is not an “usurper” of Hendrix’s position and that the votes that have taken place since Hendrix defeated Spence in the August election will not be voided.

Hendrix filed suit Aug. 18, seeking to be seated immediately and amended his suit Aug. 21 seeking to nullify any council actions taken from Aug. 18 until the suit could be decided.

Hendrix, through his attorney, Timothy LaSota, argued state law prefers elected to appointed officials and that Hendrix was thus entitled to the seat held by Spence once the Aug. 4 election results became official.

The town’s position was that when its code and other state election laws were considered, the town could seat Hendrix with other election winners on the second Tuesday in January.


Kiley, in setting the Nov. 3 date, noted state law referenced the general election and further wrote in his decision that the town’s code could not supersede state law on the matter.

He also wrote state law could not reasonably be interpreted to be the Aug. 4 election day, as votes have to be counted and the possibility of challenges have to be considered.

Kiley expressly rejected Hendrix's argument that Spence is an "usurper" to the seat and that “all actions taken by the Council with him as a purported member must be declared void.”

Nonetheless, Hendrix counted it a victory.

"I am happy that the rule of law prevailed and the court ruled in my favor," Hendrix wrote in an email. "It is unfortunate that the corruption within the town of Gilbert government is being exposed."

Spence released a statement upbrading Hendrix and calling his demands "ridiculous."

"The only 'usurping' that occured was by Mr. Hendrix and his unlawful attempt to be seated in August and void the legal actions taken by the Town Council," Spence wrote. "Mr. Hendrix's relentless pursuit to execute his self-serving agenda has resulted in a costly and unnecessary expense to the taxpayers of Gilbert and has wasted town resources."

In an interview after the statement's release, Spence said Hendrix did not give the town a chance after sending a demand notice to seek a timely opinion from outside counsel before filing his lawsuit, calling it a deliberate action.

The votes that came after the election include the appointment of Scott Anderson as mayor, replacing Jenn Daniels, and the appointment of Kathy Tilque to council, filling Anderson’s vacant seat. It also includes the council’s decision to begin an expansion of ambulance service throughout the town.
By Tom Blodgett
Raised in Arizona, Tom Blodgett has spent 30 years in journalism in Arizona and is the editor of the Gilbert edition of Community Impact Newspaper. He is a graduate of Arizona State University, where he now serves as an instructional professional in the Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication and editorial adviser to The State Press, the university's independent student media outlet.


MOST RECENT

Denise Lopez
Denise Lopez appointed HD South chief

Denise Lopez replaces Kayla Kolar, who left in 2020 to become the executive director of House of Refuge, as HD South's president and CEO.

Western Canal
Gilbert officials wanted to avoid land acquisitions along Western Canal, staff tells residents

When Gilbert staff first addressed the problem of a deteriorating sewer along the Western Canal, they hoped to avoid using eminent domain to acquire land to fix the problem, staff told residents Feb. 25.

Gilbert Public Schools Governing Board Member Lori Wood expresses her concerns about parts of the proposed school calendars for 2022-23 and 2023-24. (Screen shot from YouTube)
Gilbert Public Schools adjusts calendar; downtown Chandler adding business, multifamily and more top area news

Read the top business and community news from Chandler and Gilbert from the past week.

Arizona tourism statistics
State’s tourism struggle greater than Gilbert’s

The tourism industry has been hit hard by COVID-19 statewide, including locally in Gilbert.

Gilbert Public Safety Training Facility
Gilbert opens $85M training facility for growing police, fire forces

Gilbert is ready to open its Public Safety Training Facility under budget and ahead of schedule, officials said, allowing public safety forces to conduct expanded training in town.

Kirk Nelson, Nelson backyard
Residents hoping to save yards prepare to meet with Gilbert Town Council

Neighbors along the Western Canal path between Gilbert and Lindsey roads are hoping a meeting with Gilbert Town Council members can save them from losing their backyards to the town

Higley USD district office
Higley USD high school graduations will head back to campuses

Higley USD is planning for live high school graduations in May, but they will not be held at Arizona State University’s Wells Fargo Arena as they were pre-COVID-19.

The Meeple's Board Game Cafe
The Meeple's Cafe selling its games ahead of closing

The establishment combined food with board game play.

Maricopa County’s election equipment and software passed all tests performed by two independent firms hired to conduct the forensic audit, according to reports by two federally certified Voting System Testing Laboratories. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Maricopa County forensic audit of November election finds no issues with equipment, software

Maricopa County’s election equipment and software passed all tests performed by two independent firms hired to conduct the forensic audit.

Lori Wood
Gilbert Public Schools to start earlier, extend breaks beginning in 2022-23 school year

Final calendars await some modifications before approval, but Gilbert Public Schools will start its school year in July when the calendars take effect.

Farmer Boys
Farmer Boys set to open March 1 at Gilbert's City Gate

The 40-year-old California-based chain purchases its ingredients from local farms and purveyors when possible.

Germann Road is being improved to major arterial standards between Mustang Road and Val Vista Drive. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Left turns off limits from Lindsay to Germann through March 31 in Gilbert

The restriction is part of road work on Germann Road in which the road will be improved to major arterial roadway standards.