Charter schools fill niche, thrive in Gilbert market

Gilbert charter schools

Editor's note: This story was written before the statewide closure of schools because of the coronavirus pandemic.

In the 25 years since charter schools began operating in Arizona, Gilbert has proven to be a popular landing spot despite three highly rated public school districts serving residents.

“The perception is that the [district] schools in Gilbert are wonderful, and they really are,” Leading Edge Academy founder Delmer Geesey said. “So not everybody comes running to the charters because of the terrible district schools. ... It’s a different kind of niche that charters get.”

However, charter officials said the town’s growth of the past quarter century as well as its family-first culture have proven inviting to charter schools.

The end result is Gilbert has more charters within its boundaries than the state’s other municipalities except for Phoenix, Tucson and Mesa, all of which have much larger populations.

That, officials said, gives Gilbert residents convenient options to make choices for the best fit for their families and spurs competition that makes everyone better.

“For any school—charter, public, private—I just want to make sure the students are educated,” Gilbert Public Schools Superintendent Shane McCord said. “If you choose not to go here, that’s your choice. But I hope where you end up,

you’re going to get a great experience, and you’re going to get educated.”

Understanding charter schools

Charter schools are independently operated public schools that operate in Arizona under a contract from the Arizona State Board for Charter Schools. Like district schools, charter schools must accept students regardless of race, gender or religion or needs like special education.

Gilbert Town Council Member Jared Taylor, who also is president and CEO of four Heritage Academy charter schools outside the town, said the public often misunderstands them, confusing them with private schools.

“The way I simplify it for people is a government contractor,” Taylor said. “I’ll use the analogy of a battleship. We can have the government create an agency to create battleships, or we can hire Northrop Grumman.”

Taylor said such contracting relationships are better for the economy.

“[A charter school is] a public school, privately operated,” he said. “A district school is a public school, publicly operated. They’re fundamentally different things.”

Like district schools, charters get state funding from a formula that is based in large part on enrollment. However, charter schools cannot go to voters for bonds or maintenance and operations overrides, so the state’s formula for charter schools pays more per student than for district school students.

Charters can get additional revenue for building from private revenue bonds. Like district schools, they can receive state public school tax credit donations that can be used for extracurricular activities or certain fees.

When the Arizona Legislature passed laws in 1994 that allowed for charter schools in the state, many public schools reacted negatively to the changes and the new schools that opened in the laws’ wake, said Lynn Robershotte, superintendent of Eduprize, which in 1995 was the first charter school to open in the state. She said districts were concerned charters would pull away the best students and accompanying state funding from districts.

“I think with newness or any change can come fear or dissettling,” she said. “As that’s evolved, it’s far less so.”

Attraction of Gilbert

Robershotte and Eduprize co-founder JoAnna Curtis were working in Mesa Public Schools when they decided to open a charter.

Robershotte said she originally wanted to open small magnet schools in at-risk neighborhoods. But she had connections in education in Gilbert.

“It came down to where you could find a facility because we already had a clamoring,” she said. “We had a waitlist before we opened, when we said we were going to do this, just from the names of the educators that I brought in that first year.”

Gilbert’s population in 1995, according to the Maricopa Association of Governments, was 57,085, the “inflection point” for the town’s growth, Taylor said.

That, along with available land, sparked charter growth, he said.

Taylor noted that it can take two to three years for a district to get together a bond campaign and pass it before building new schools. He called charter schools more nimble in being able to raise funds and get into a facility. That enabled charters to pop up quickly to meet the education needs in a community growing so quickly.

“We couldn’t build [district] schools fast enough, but the charter schools filled a huge void because we were [growing] and in terms of bonds and the school’s facilities, we were just not keeping up,” he said. “So that’s one way it’s been very, very effective, is matching the growth cycle.”

Data bears Taylor’s assertions out. Gilbert has 22 charter schools with their main campuses in its boundaries, according to the Arizona State Board of Charter Schools.

When adjusted for population, Gilbert has greater density of charter schools for its population than any of the Maricopa County suburbs of more than 100,000 people with the exception of Peoria, another city with a rapidly growing population.

Two suburbs of fewer than 100,000 people, but also showing explosive growth now, are undergoing similar patterns of attracting charter schools. Goodyear has nine charter schools for a population of 82,837 and Queen Creek 10 with a population of 36,053.

Taylor said charter schools serve about 18%-20% of the education market of 1.1 million students in Arizona, and that is growing at 1%-2% annually.

“I’ll be interested to see, is it tapering or is it continuing?” Taylor said. “At some point there’ll be enough of a charter product in the education marketplace because it’s been clear over 25 years, the majority of people still choose district schools, and that’s OK. The point is to fill the gaps.”

Education competition effect

District public school officials summarize their view of charter schools today simply: they are competition.

“It’s made us step up and look at how we market [and] the type of programming we provide the kids,” said GPS’ McCord, who touted districts’ comprehensive nature. “And we have to be very diligent with our community and help them understand the advantages [of district schools].”

That is how state lawmakers said they wanted districts to react when passing school choice legislation.

Taylor said districts either embraced the competition or grew defensive. He called Chandler USD, one of the three districts serving part of Gilbert, perhaps the “premier example” of a district that chose to compete.

“They started to say, ‘You know what, we’re not going to whine. We’re going to compete,’” Taylor said. “And they made a commitment, and they gave Dr. [Camille] Casteel, who is an outstanding superintendent, the directive to go in and win. And what they’re doing, they’re very effective.”

Geesey from Leading Edge said the competition with district schools is friendly and makes both charter and district schools better.

“If you think about it, we’re all on the same team,” he said. “It’s these kids that we’re trying to help. And sometimes you can do a better job than me, and sometimes I can do a better job. And if you can understand that, then the piece of the pie that I’m going to get is just the right size for me.”

By Tom Blodgett
Raised in Arizona, Tom Blodgett has spent 30 years in journalism in Arizona and is the editor of the Gilbert edition of Community Impact Newspaper. He is a graduate of Arizona State University, where he now serves as an instructional professional in the Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication and editorial adviser to The State Press, the university's independent student media outlet.


Gov. Doug Ducey issued an emergency declaration and imposed a statewide curfew May 31. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Arizona Gov. Doug Ducey issues statewide declaration of emergency, curfew

Gov. Doug Ducey issued an emergency declaration and imposed a statewide curfew May 31.

Mayor Jenn Daniels, shown here addressing the audience at the 2020 Digital State of the Town, has issued a new emergency declaration for Gilbert. (Tom Blodgett/Community Impact Newspaper)
Back-to-school scenarios, road closures: News from Gilbert, Chandler

Read some of Community Impact Newspaper’s latest coverage of Gilbert and Chandler.

Bradley Rogers, A/C Rangers Heating and Cooling
Home contractors still finding business through pandemic

A large percentage of businesses have been hit hard by the coronavirus pandemic, and while some home contractor and service businesses in Gilbert have followed that trend, others are seeing an uptick in need

Here are the coronavirus updates to know today in Gilbert. (Community Impact staff)
COVID-19: Gilbert sees 8 new cases May 29, Maricopa County sees 218 new cases and 15 deaths

Across Gilbert's six ZIP codes, there were 295 confirmed positive cases of COVID-19 on May 29, according to data from the state

Gov. Doug Ducey spoke May 28 to provide a coronavirus update. (Community Impact staff)
Governor says school will resume as planned for the next school year, releases guidance for summer schools, youth sports

Gov. Doug Ducey said Arizona schools may plan to reopen as planned for the upcoming 2020-21 academic year at a press conference May 28

(Source: Town of Gilbert/Community Impact Newspaper)
Town encouraged by first COVID-19 revenue look, but April, May results will define budget

Gilbert’s revenue in March, when the effects of the coronavirus pandemic first hit, along with the town’s experience navigating the Great Recession, have left the town optimistic about making it through the fiscal year relatively unscathed

Gov. Doug Ducey announced relief aid to municipalities including Gilbert and Chandler at a May 27 press conference. (Community Impact staff)
Gilbert, Chandler to get relief funds and more: News from the Phoenix area

Read the latest Gilbert and Chandler news from Community Impact Newspaper's website.

Gov. Doug Ducey announced relief aid to municipalities including Gilbert and Chandler at a May 27 press conference. (Community Impact staff)
Gilbert, Chandler to receive more than $29 million each in relief funds from state

Gilbert and Chandler will be among the local governments receiving coronavirus relief and recovery dollars as part of a plan unveiled May 27 by Gov. Doug Ducey

Rebecca Sunenshine
Summer campers, staff should be screened daily, Maricopa County says

Campers and staff at summer camps should be screened daily if such camps are to be opened safely this summer, the county’s top disease control official said.

HD South
HD South set to reopen June 2

HD South, Gilbert’s arts, culture and history museum, will reopen June 2 with new restrictions in place

Gilbert Public Schools
Gilbert Public Schools preparing three back-to-school scenarios

A Gilbert Public Schools task force is preparing three back-to-school scenarios for the 2020-21 school year with a preference for in-person learning, officials told the governing board May 26.

Gilbert Feeding Families
Gilbert Feeding Families food drive brings in enough to supply 250,000 meals

The townwide food drive May 15-17 collected enough food and cash to supply a quarter-million meals to people in need, according to town officials