Gilbert Town Council approves apartment project despite neighbors’ objections

The Gilbert Municipal I Building acts as Town Hall and is where the Town Council meets.

The Gilbert Municipal I Building acts as Town Hall and is where the Town Council meets.

The Gilbert Town Council unanimously approved a minor General Plan amendment Sept. 19 that will allow an apartment complex to be built in the Cooley Station despite objections from neighbors.

The Gilbert Planning Commission previously unanimously approved the plan to change the zoning from village center to multifamily residential medium density with a planned area development overlay. The Town Council voted 5-0 to approve the change with Council Member Aimee Yentes absent and Council Member Jordan Ray, who had been present for the meeting by phone, not giving a voice vote.

A group of neighbors to the planned complex from the Fincher Fields at Cooley Station homeowners association said they felt developers had been “disingenuous” about plans for the land.

“We are vested in this community,” Ariel Jeter said. “We've built in this community with the vision that this was going to be a town center open and available. We were given color plot maps, for lack of a better term … of what was promised to us was going to be directly in front of our homes. If we had been told three-story apartment buildings were going to be directly in front of our homes, we never would have purchased there.”

Among the objections put forward were a lack of a fence or gate between the complex and the homes, shared driveway space, traffic issues and the negative effect on home values.

Greg Davis, who represented the Gieszi family who owns the property, said neighborhood meetings at the beginning of the project did show a more traditional apartment complex with gates and fences. However, town staff later asked for the changes to promote the Gateway Village area’s walkability and connectedness, as well as for traffic safety.

He also noted current zoning standards allow the ownership to build up to six stories with higher density by right.

Council members in their comments talked about the history of what the town has sought for the area and how difficult it has been to get that vision to come to fruition until now.

Mayor Jenn Daniels told the neighbors if the longtime plans for the area had not been properly communicated to them, “that was unfair to you."

“I am sorry if that was the message that was communicated, but I have looked at these plans for 10 years now, and it's always been designed for a high-density product along that corridor, and so I do think we are honoring that through this project,” Daniels said. “And I also am very excited about some of the retail options that you are going to be getting in this area that will make a difference and that will increase your property values as well.”

Council members urged neighbors to stay involved in the design process as it goes through town, where some of their concerns can be addressed.

Transit issues

In other items, Development Services Director Kyle Mieras and Transportation Planner Nichole McCarty presented to council about transit issues in town, noting the rising costs and decreased funding, particularly for Americans with Disabilities Act-certified riders.

The town has two programs for ADA riders: Paratransit, which is mandated by federal law, and RideChoice, which is not mandated. McCarty compared it to Uber and Lyft.

Paratransit is required to be maintained within three-fourths of a mile of existing fixed routes for buses, but Gilbert offers it throughout the town.

However, Paratransit services are more expensive to the town, McCarty said. She asked the council for permission for staff to explore rolling back Paratransit to only federally mandated areas. Mesa and Maricopa County have made similar moves recently. No vote was taken, but council gave direction for staff to do so.

Other business

• Plan Review and Inspection Manager Larry Taylor from the Gilbert Development Services Department reviewed for council planned changes to the town’s building and fire codes. The town is looking to simplify the code while maintaining safety levels. The changes will be up for vote in November and would take effect Jan. 1 if adopted.

• Council unanimously rejected a $6.5 million bid from Artis U.S. Holdings II to purchase 36.66 acres of land at the northeast corner of East Germann Road and South Mustang Drive. Council members gave no reasons. However, the land, which was originally slated to be the site of the Public Safety Training Facility, was appraised for nearly $9.4 million, according to town documents, with proceeds from the sale being put into the construction of the facility. The facility is now being built on 50 acres near the northwest corner of Power and Pecos roads.
By Tom Blodgett
Raised in Arizona, Tom Blodgett has spent 30 years in journalism in Arizona and is the editor of the Gilbert edition of Community Impact Newspaper. He is a graduate of Arizona State University, where he now serves as an instructional professional in the Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication and editorial adviser to The State Press, the university's independent student media outlet.


Gov. Doug Ducey spoke May 28 to provide a coronavirus update. (Community Impact staff)
Governor says school will resume as planned for the next school year, releases guidance for summer schools, youth sports

Gov. Doug Ducey said Arizona schools may plan to reopen as planned for the upcoming 2020-21 academic year at a press conference May 28

(Source: Town of Gilbert/Community Impact Newspaper)
Town encouraged by first COVID-19 revenue look, but April, May results will define budget

Gilbert’s revenue in March, when the effects of the coronavirus pandemic first hit, along with the town’s experience navigating the Great Recession, have left the town optimistic about making it through the fiscal year relatively unscathed

Gov. Doug Ducey announced relief aid to municipalities including Gilbert and Chandler at a May 27 press conference. (Community Impact staff)
Gilbert, Chandler to get relief funds and more: News from the Phoenix area

Read the latest Gilbert and Chandler news from Community Impact Newspaper's website.

Gov. Doug Ducey announced relief aid to municipalities including Gilbert and Chandler at a May 27 press conference. (Community Impact staff)
Gilbert, Chandler to receive more than $29 million each in relief funds from state

Gilbert and Chandler will be among the local governments receiving coronavirus relief and recovery dollars as part of a plan unveiled May 27 by Gov. Doug Ducey

Rebecca Sunenshine
Summer campers, staff should be screened daily, Maricopa County says

Campers and staff at summer camps should be screened daily if such camps are to be opened safely this summer, the county’s top disease control official said.

HD South
HD South set to reopen June 2

HD South, Gilbert’s arts, culture and history museum, will reopen June 2 with new restrictions in place

Gilbert Public Schools
Gilbert Public Schools preparing three back-to-school scenarios

A Gilbert Public Schools task force is preparing three back-to-school scenarios for the 2020-21 school year with a preference for in-person learning, officials told the governing board May 26.

Gilbert Feeding Families
Gilbert Feeding Families food drive brings in enough to supply 250,000 meals

The townwide food drive May 15-17 collected enough food and cash to supply a quarter-million meals to people in need, according to town officials

Dr. Cara Christ, director of the Arizona Department of Health Services provided an update May 26 on the capacity of the state health care system. (Community Impact staff)
Latest COVID-19 model shows Arizona can meet a health care surge

Arizona's current resources, including inpatient beds, intensive care unit beds and ventilators, are sufficient to meet a health care surge due to COVID-19, according to a recent predictive model.

Here are the coronavirus updates to know today in Gilbert. (Community Impact staff)
COVID-19: Gilbert sees 5 new cases May 28, Maricopa County sees 261 new cases and 5 deaths

Across Gilbert's six ZIP codes, there were 282 confirmed positive cases of COVID-19 on May 27, according to data from the state

Rachelle Kuzyk began her job as the city of Chandler's new library manager May 20. (Courtesy city of Chandler)
Public swim hours, libraries and more: News from Chandler, Gilbert

Read the latest news from Gilbert and Chandler here.

Gilbert Main Street
Gilbert has suffered through epidemics before

A researcher for HD South dug up several episodes of Gilbert dealing with epidemics