Amid a state investigation into its governing board and a freeze to its superintendent search, Houston ISD officials are confronting another troubling reality: a drop in enrollment.
To avoid a costly decline, officials are ramping up marketing efforts with messaging designed to emphasize college-readiness efforts and have partnered with the University of Houston and Rice University for the district’s first-ever comprehensive look at what factors are driving the enrollment changes.
“We want to dive deep and learn the why, and go beyond the data we have now. What’s going on? What are the contributing factors?” said Rick Cruz, HISD’s chief strategy and innovation officer.
Schools in the Bellaire, West University and Meyerland areas, however, are showing increases in enrollment, demographic data shows. The region has some of the district’s top-performing schools and popular magnet programs, attracting students from the entire district, such as Bellaire High School, where 25% of its students come from outside of its zone. That said, one in three elementary students in the area attended a private or charter school in 2018.
Parents say the district’s main challenge will be overcoming its leadership credibility problem at the board level.
“The antics of the board have to be addressed,” said Beth Lane, president of the parent-teacher organization at Pershing Middle School. “Anybody who was on the fence about public school, now they’re thinking, ‘Let’s go to private and not worry about that’ ... or they’re moving out to the suburbs.”
Forces at work
In 2017-18, HISD experienced a decline of about 2,000 students. In 2018-19, another 4,500 fewer students were signed up for classes, bringing total enrollment to 209,772. Next year, 1,500 fewer are projected. Combined, that is a total decline of about 3%.
“We need to understand if this is a larger trend,” Cruz said. “A big part of the decrease is happening at the elementary level, which means it could be a harbinger of what is to come. And so, how much of this is really in our control?”
From 2014-18, elementary school enrollment, not including prekindergarten, has dropped almost 3% districtwide. In the same time period, U.S. Census data shows HISD’s school-age population grew by almost 2.5%. Because HISD allows a family to apply for enrollment at any school, some schools grow while others may shrink.
National statistics have differing projections for demographic trends. On one hand, the U.S. Department of Education estimates total K-12 enrollment in Texas will increase by 15% by 2027. Another study by the Western Interstate Commission for Higher Education projects a national decline of graduating seniors by 6.5% by 2027, principally led by a decline in birth rates.
“Declining birth rates is absolutely a key factor in play,” said Bob Templeton, whose firm provides demographics reports and consulting to over 80 school districts in Texas. “We detected a drop in kindergarten enrollment about four years ago, and it’s been continuing to decline. That had never happened before.”
Millennials are waiting longer to establish households and have families, he said, and without immigration, many areas would be stagnant or would shrink even more. Another factor is affordable housing, he said.
“We are seeing that in Austin; housing has become so expensive that populations are moving out. That is definitely taking place,” Templeton said.
Tougher competition
On billboards, social media and movie theater ads, HISD will tout its college-readiness credentials, featuring students who gained acceptance into Columbia University, Harvard University and others.
These success stories are from Cruz’s Emerge program, which is funding part of the marketing plan. Emerge, which received $13 million from the Houston
Endowment last year, adds resources and after-school programs to prepare potential first-generation college populations for higher education and beyond, Cruz said. With over 2,000 students in the program, it is proving to be very successful, he said.
“We’re seeing 95 percent of students graduate in four years or are on track to do so, and we are talking about mostly low-income, minority students who generally have lower retention and graduation rates,” he said.
The additional student support and college focus mirrors efforts by some of district’s biggest competitors: charter schools.
Data from the Texas Education Agency shows HISD has been losing an increasing number of students to non-district charters. In the most recent school year, more than 38,000 students transferred out of the district, with over 90 percent of them going to charters, and almost half of those going to KIPP and YES Prep schools. Only about 3,000 transferred in, meaning HISD had a net loss of about 35,000 students, or about 16.7% of its current enrollment. As the district’s overall population has grown, charter schools seem to be taking on a greater share of the growth away from HISD schools.
Because these are out-of-district charter schools, HISD does not receive any funding allocations for those students. With its state funding allocation averaging a little over $1,000 per student according to the TEA, that means HISD missed out on as much as $35 million—roughly equivalent to its current budget deficit—in 2018.
Bellaire, Meyerland and West University residents also have access to high-performing private schools, and estimates by the U.S. Census show they could be increasingly preferred, with an enrollment of about 28,600 in HISD’s boundaries in 2017. That number is up by 7% in four years, the estimates show.
For children zoned to schools in Bellaire, Meyerland and West University, an estimated 4,800 students in the district attended private schools in 2017-18, an analysis of district data shows. Another 830 attended charters.
Competition is about to heat up, as IDEA Public Schools, a successful charter system that launched in the Rio Grande Valley, is set to open four campuses in Houston in 2020, with plans to eventually have 16 more.
Changing the narrative
This competitive environment is forcing schools to rethink their entire approach, Templeton said.
“Today’s parents are expecting schools to be more customer service-oriented,” he said. “Schools are used to a mindset where things are rigid, from bell times to pickup and drop-off. … But parents now have a choice.”
Amid these competitive forces, the district is mired in a potential state takeover of its governing board, a situation that is eroding trust among parents, who have the option to move or enroll their children elsewhere, said Jasmine Jenkins, executive director of Houstonians for Great Public Schools.
“People recognize that and don’t want to invest their children’s future in something that’s obviously not moving forward,” she said.
District officials acknowledge these concerns are a factor, and the new study will help school officials hear parents’ concerns and address them, Cruz said.
“At the end of the day, regardless of what’s happening outside of our schools, we need to do what’s right for our students,” he said.
By expanding programs such as Emerge and looking at improving access to International Baccalaureate coursework, the district can become even more competitive, he said.
“There’s a misconception out there that a charter or private school is the only way to get a top-notch education,” HISD Chief Communication Officer Rebecca Suarez said. “But we have programs at every school that can match that.”
