City of Brentwood updates home elevation codes

Image description
Image description
When Mary Hesselrode and her family moved to Brentwood in 2015, they knew their home had flooded in the 2010 Nashville flood, which brought as much as 13 inches of rain to the Greater Nashville area and flooded thousands of homes and

businesses, according to historical flood data.

However, she said she was not aware that her home had flooded in other years, multiple times.

“At the time we purchased our home, we were told that our home only flooded in 2010, [and] most of Nashville flooded in 2010,” she said. “So, we didn’t think much of it. That was documented. We were like, ‘Okay, we got flood insurance.’ Flood insurance at the time seemed reasonable.”

Six months after they moved into their new home, the Hesselrodes got a letter from the Federal Emergency Management Agency stating their home had flooded on six previous occasions.

“Because of that, we were put into a category of what is called a ‘repetitive loss,’ and so when you’re a repetitive loss, your insurance goes up significantly, and that’s what occurred to us,” Hesselrode said.

Hesselrode said their annual flood insurance increased by about $2,000 and has risen each year since.

“We have been told by FEMA that it will go up 7%-10% every year unless we mitigate, and ‘mitigate,’ just, obviously, is a fancy word for correcting the problem,” she said.

City codes

After looking into buyouts from FEMA with no results, Hesselrode and a handful of other residents went to the Brentwood City Commission this past summer in hopes that the city might be able to help.

To mitigate future flooding, homes in the area would need to be elevated. However, prior to October, the city of Brentwood did not allow residents to raise their homes high enough to lower flood insurance rates. On Oct. 28, the city of Brentwood formally approved an amendment to the city’s building codes, allowing homeowners to raise their homes up to 7.5 feet above the ground, more than two feet higher than the previous maximum of 5 feet, according to the city.

According to background information for the amended code, the previous maximum height of five feet for elevations was established to prevent parts of a home below the flood line from being used for living space.

The city’s code, along with recommendations from FEMA, also requires homes that are elevated to be raised a minimum of two feet above the FEMA-designated flood line, which can vary by home, according to the city. That stipulation was also in the previous version of the city code.

City Manager Kirk Bednar said one of the reasons homeowners are seeing such a sharp increase in their flood insurance premiums is because the federal government is no longer providing funding to help lower insurance costs for homeowners.

“In the last few years ... the federal government has been phasing out whatever subsidies it’s been providing relative to flood insurance,” Bednar said. “So, the flood insurance costs are rising dramatically because of that lack of a subsidy. That’s putting the pressure on some of the homeowners here in town—and really, everywhere that that applies—to look ... at getting out of the floodway and the floodway fringe.”

Brentwood residents are not the only ones in these areas calling for homes to be raised. Earlier this year, 35 homes along the Harpeth River in Franklin qualified to be raised 3 feet above the flood line following a years-long study from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.

Although the area has not seen flooding events like the one in 2010 in recent years, historic flood data from FEMA shows Williamson County sees—on average—at least one flood event each year.

Floodway options

One significant change to the city of Brentwood’s codes relates to homes located inside the floodway—an area near a body of water—Bednar said. Previously, under the old codes, Brentwood homes located in a floodway could not be raised at all for fear of causing other homes in the area to flood as a result. However, under the new codes, homeowners living in the floodway can raise their homes to the maximum elevation of 7.5 feet, but only if they can have an engineer confirm that it will not negatively affect nearby homeowners.

“The extra condition here for floodways is a standard condition in that they would have to do an engineering study to prove a ‘no-rise’ certificate, meaning that whatever the work is going to do would cause no rise in the overall flood levels throughout the community,” he said. “That’s an extra condition for any work in the floodway.”

Additionally, the city code says homes that need to be raised more than 7.5 feet to be above the flood lines can be raised higher, so long as they are raised on piers on the back and sides of the home, with a solid wall with flood vents on the front facade, according to the city. “That would apply also in the floodway with that same no-rise certificate,” Bednar said. “Essentially, what this does is it provides some extra options for homeowners in the floodway and the floodway fringe on elevating their homes.”

City officials said while the change of the codes took weeks of planning on the city’s part—and getting approval from the Tennessee Emergency Management Agency—they were glad to give homeowners another option for mitigation.

“It’s a lot of work—that’s the part of government you don’t see,” Vice Mayor Ken Travis said. “You think, ‘Oh, we’ll just raise it two feet.’ But there’s a whole lot of work that went into that.”

For homeowners like Hesselrode, getting the city codes changed is just one step on the road for residents hoping to mitigate future flooding and get their rates lowered, but she said she is glad to have made some progress. She said while home elevation can be expensive for residents, the savings in flood insurance rates can help to offset costs over time.

“The main point is homeowners now have an option, which, before, they did not,” Hesselrode said. “Obviously, there are risks that go along with elevations, but at least it’s an option. Before we had that as an option, we were just going to continuously increase our flood insurance 7%- 10% every year.”
By Wendy Sturges
A Houston native and graduate of St. Edward's University in Austin, Wendy Sturges has worked as a community journalist covering local government, health care, business and development since 2011. She has worked with Community Impact since 2015 as a reporter and editor and moved to Tennessee in 2019.


With a clinical background in internal, pulmonary and critical care medicine, Corry has been with BCM for 20 years. He now focuses primarily on inflammatory lung diseases, such as asthma and smoking-related chronic obstructive pulmonary diseases. (Graphic by Ronald Winters/Community Impact Newspaper)
Q&A: Baylor College of Medicine's Dr. David Corry discusses immunity, vaccine production amid COVID-19 pandemic

Rapid development and distribution of a vaccine worldwide and successful achievement of herd immunity will be key players in determining the lifespan of the COVID-19 pandemic, said Dr. David Corry, a professor of Medicine in the Immunology, Allergy and Rheumatology Section at Baylor College of Medicine.

Here are the coronavirus data updates to know today in Tennessee. (Community Impact staff)
Tennessee coronavirus cases rise by over 1,900 in 24 hours

In Davidson County, there have been at least 12,935 reported cases. Williamson County has reported 1,670 cases.

Williamson County Schools released a reopening framework plan for students and families on July 9 before school begins in early August, with students given the option to receive on-campus or remote instruction. (Courtesy Pixabay)
Williamson County Schools’ 2020-21 plan plus four other Nashville stories

Here are five recent updates from Greater Nashville on plans for education in the fall, governmental moves toward increased public safety and more.

Williamson County Schools released a reopening framework plan for students and families on July 9 before school begins in early August, with students given the option to receive on-campus or remote instruction. (Courtesy Pixabay)
Williamson County Schools releases plans for optional return to on-campus learning in fall

The district will be in communication with the county health department to determine whether to adjust plans based on the number of active COVID-19 cases in the county.

(Courtesy Pixabay)
Columbia State Community College to offer hybrid of virtual, in-person instruction for fall semester

The college, which has a campus in Franklin, said all lecture courses will be live streamed via Zoom, allowing students and faculty to interact in real time.

The Tennessee State Capitol Commission voted July 9 to remove the Nathan Bedford Forrest bust from the state capitol. (Screenshot via
Commission votes to remove Nathan Bedford Forrest bust from Tennessee Capitol, but it will not be moved just yet

The final decision on moving the bust will be made by the Tennessee Historic Commission.

Tennessee coronavirus cases rise by over 1,600 in 24 hours

The daily totals also include 710 cumulative deaths, 3,088 cumulative hospitalizations and an estimated 33,609 recoveries to date.

Census worker
2020 census: Bureau prepares nonresponse follow-up field operations

For individuals who have not responded to the 2020 census, one of about 500,000 census takers will visit the their household between Aug. 11-Oct. 31.

Here are the coronavirus data updates to know today in Tennessee. (Community Impact staff)
Tennessee coronavirus cases rise by over 2,400 in 24 hours, marking the largest single-day increase in cases to date

The daily totals also include 685 cumulative deaths, 3,025 cumulative hospitalizations and an estimated 32,736 recoveries to date.

A new committee has been formed to discuss the possibility of changing the Rebel mascot of Franklin High School and is seeking feedback from the public. (Alex Hosey/Community Impact Newspaper)
New committee to explore changing Franklin High mascot

Franklin High School’s mascot was originally the Pioneers, but was changed to the Rebels in 1936.