Franklin puts limits on short-term rentals

The city of Franklin has seen a large increase in the number of short-term rental properties operating in the area.
The city of Franklin has seen a large increase in the number of short-term rental properties operating in the area.

The city of Franklin has seen a large increase in the number of short-term rental properties operating in the area.

Image description
New rules will change where and how property owners can operate short-term rentals in the city.
Image description
When Ellie Westman Chin started in her position as the president and CEO of the Williamson County Convention and Visitors Bureau five years ago, she said the bureau formulated a strategic plan with the hope of bringing 2 million visitors to the area by the end of 2020.

“That was a pretty aggressive goal based on what our growth had already been,” Westman Chin said. “But in 2018, we had 1.72 million visitors, so it got us really within striking distance of that number.”

With the growing number of tourists coming to Franklin came an increase in the number of short-term vacation rental properties in the city limits, rising from 220 active rentals in 2016 to over 500 in late 2019, according to AirDNA, a website that tracks the performance of short-term rentals.

As a part of the city of Franklin’s recently enacted citywide zoning ordinance, which was developed throughout 2019 and adopted at the end of the year, new limitations have been placed on owners and operators of short-term rentals within the city’s residential districts in order to preserve neighborhood character.

“We heard very clearly from residents the concern about short-term vacation rentals, bringing in commercial uses into residential neighborhoods and the intrinsic value of residential neighborhoods and neighbors,” said Kelly Dannenfelser, assistant director of planning and sustainability for the city. “To keep the residential zoning districts truly residential, we added additional use regulations in those districts.”


Maintaining residential character

The zoning ordinance, as passed at BOMA’s Dec. 10 meeting, requires new short-term rental properties to be confined to one lot per property and to have the owner reside on the property within residential districts in the city—districts where city staff said the majority of short-term rentals existed.

Short-term rentals already operating within residential districts before enacting the new ordinance are grandfathered in; that policy will still apply if the short-term rental is passed on to a blood relative.

In public discussions regarding the new ordinance’s limits on short term rentals, the majority of public input was in favor of the ordinance, while a few residents and operators of short-term vacation rentals had issues with the possibility of the ordinance interfering with their businesses.

“You hear stories from both sides,” Westman Chin said. “You hear the stories in neighborhoods where there are bachelorette parties and late-night partying and trash in the streets, and then, you hear the stories where people do exactly what they should do and they behave.”

Lynne McAlister, a Franklin resident and president of the Downtown Neighborhood Association, praised the ordinance and spoke out against an influx of short-term rentals in the area that she said compromised the residential character of Franklin.

“Where I live now, within half a block, there are three Airbnb’s. Two of them are non-owner-occupied,” McAlister said. “I think the question we have to ask ourselves and wrestle with is, ‘Who are our neighborhoods designed for?’ ... The best tourist in the world cannot be a neighbor.”

However, Franklin resident Joseph Fuson said he had nothing but good experiences with people to whom he rented a home at a short-term rental he operated on Church Street. Fuson asked the Board of Mayor and Alderman not to extend the zoning’s limits in certain zones.

“I wouldn’t want you to extend [short-term rental limits] to the downtown area, to the [office residential] zone, to the commercial zones,” Fuson said. “These are the types of places [from which] we want these people coming into downtown. We don’t want hotels to be the only option because a lot of people don’t want to stay in hotels, but they want to come downtown and spend their money and enjoy this amazing city.”

Dannenfelser said there were no additional rules in the ordinance against operating short-term rentals in commercial districts, leaving homeowners in those areas the option to operate a non-owner-occupied rental.

“Short-term vacation rentals are permitted in the office residential district, the central commercial [district] and [the] downtown district, which are all in central Franklin, but commercial uses are already permitted in those districts, so it didn’t make any sense to require an owner to live there because there aren’t those residences nearby to protect,” Dannenfelser said.

City staff said all short-term vacation rentals, regardless of where they are located, require permit approval from the city in order to operate, the regulation of which is primarily complaint-based.

“[Short-term rentals] do have a fit for Franklin because we’re a very attractive tourist destination,” City Administrator Eric Stuckey said. “But we didn’t want to lose neighborhood character and cohesion just because we allowed these absentee-type short-term rentals to come in and prevail in certain neighborhoods.”


MOST RECENT

tiny little donuts opened a new location at 1203 Murfreesboro Road, Franklin in 2020. (Wendy Sturges/Community Impact Newspaper)
22 restaurants that opened in 2020 in Franklin, Brentwood; plus 6 more coming in 2021

Check out which new places have opened in your neighborhood.

A new alderperson will be sworn into the Franklin Board of Mayor and Aldermen on Feb. 9. (Screenshot via City of Franklin)
Franklin BOMA appoints former Mayor John Schroer to vacant city seat

Schroer served as mayor from 2007-11 and will fill an at-large seat left vacant following the death of former Alderperson Pearl Bransford in November.

Outdoor dining rules for businesses in Brentwood have been extended. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Brentwood extends temporary outdoor dining guidelines through April

The resolution extends rules on outdoor dining spaces through April 30.

(Community Impact Newspaper staff)
DATA: Williamson County's population grew by 16% in 5 years; plus more community data for Franklin, Brentwood

Williamson County's population growth over the last five years was more than four times the state's growth rate of 3.9%.

The Tennessee Department of Health issued an update to its vaccine plan Jan. 22. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Tennessee Department of Health updates COVID-19 vaccine plan to move up families of medically fragile children, correctional officers

The TDH has also updated preliminary timelines on when those who qualify for the vaccine based on age could receive it.

A new eatery is now open on Carothers Parkway. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Chrysalis Modern Italian now open in Cool Springs

A new eatery is now open on Carothers Parkway.

The state has taken steps in the past weeks to vaccinate at-risk populations. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Vets age 65+ can get VA vaccine; Perry's Steakhouse to open and more top Franklin, Brentwood news

Read the top stories from the past week from the Franklin and Brentwood areas.

Williamson County Schools has named 21 open-zoned schools for the 2021-22 school year. (Wendy Sturges/Community Impact Newspaper)
Williamson County Schools approves open zoning for select campuses

For parents of students who wish to change schools before the start of the 2021-22 school year, the Williamson County Schools board of education has approved 21 open-zoned schools.

The state has taken steps in the past weeks to vaccinate at-risk populations. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Tennessee VA now offering COVID-19 vaccine for veterans age 65 and older

Veterans in Tennessee age 65 and older may now qualify for the COVID-19 vaccine through the Tennessee Valley Healthcare System and the U.S. Department of Veteran Affairs.

A number of parents and community members have called for more parental involvement and district training regarding racism in schools. (Community Impact staff)
Parents, teachers call for more training to address racism in Williamson County Schools

During the WCS Board of Education meeting Jan. 19, a number of community members spoke about a lack of training and resources to address racial tension at schools, as well as a need for the district to more directly address incidents.

(Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Williamson County active COVID-19 cases drop more than 20% in past week

Active cases have been consistently above 2,000 in recent weeks.

Williamson County Schools, state address effects of COVID-19 on learning loss

According to preliminary data from assessments given to students in the fall, Williamson County Schools officials calculated that some students have lost as much as 9% proficiency in reading and math as a result of school closure last spring. This number is lower than the 50%-65% decreases estimated by the Tennessee Department of Education officials in September; however, local officials said, there is still catching up to do.