Spring, Klein and Cy-Fair ISDs reflect on 2018-19 accountability ratings

(Ronald Winters/Community Impact Newspaper)
(Ronald Winters/Community Impact Newspaper)

(Ronald Winters/Community Impact Newspaper)

Image description
(Ronald Winters/Community Impact Newspaper)
Image description
(Ronald Winters/Community Impact Newspaper)
Spring ISD’s overall 2018-19 Texas Education Agency accountability rating improved by eight points from the previous year—outpacing increases from neighboring districts including Klein and Cy-Fair ISDs. But the district’s rating remains more than 10 points below those districts, according to TEA accountability rating results.

Overall, seven SISD campuses, or 18.9% of all rated campuses in SISD, received F’s in 2018-19—up from three in 2017-18. At the same time, four SISD campuses, or 10.9% of all rated campuses in SISD, received A’s in 2018-19—up from one in 2017-18.

“The backslide performance at the majority of the middle schools and the downgrade of performance at two elementary schools that received an F was the greatest loss,” said Jennifer Cobb, SISD assistant superintendent for research, accountability and testing.

The TEA’s accountability rating system evaluates public schools statewide by annually assigning numerical scores and corresponding A-F letter grades to public school districts and individual campuses. The system was first implemented in 2017-18.

The TEA released 2018-19 ratings Aug. 15 for 1,201 public school districts and charter schools. Based on the results, the percentage of public schools that received A’s and B’s increased statewide, while the percentage of those that received C’s, D’s and F’s decreased.

“Performance continues to improve in Texas schools because of the tireless effort of Texas teachers, administrators and staff,” Education Commissioner Mike Morath said in an Aug. 15 news release. “I am particularly proud of the educators at the 296 high-poverty schools that achieved an A rating.”

However, despite overall rating improvements across the state, local campuses experienced varying degrees of success, forcing districts to build on the success of some campuses while addressing the shortcomings of others through targeted improvement plans.

Recapping results

Locally, SISD’s district rating jumped from 70 in 2017-18 to 78 in 2018-19 while KISD’s rating improved from 85 to 89, and CFISD’s rating remained steady at 89. Despite these gains, SISD had the highest percentage of campuses receive F ratings—or unacceptable performance—of many neighboring districts.

“We are proud of those schools that grew their achievement, especially those who earned an A or B,” SISD Superintendent Rodney Watson said in a statement. “We also recognize that we still have a lot of work to do to ensure all of our schools are providing the best education possible.”

Some SISD campuses saw double-digit rate increases from the 2017-18 school year, while others experienced double-digit rate declines. For example, Link Elementary saw a 24-point increase year over year—a success SISD officials attribute to effective leadership.

“All of our kids deserve to go to an ‘A’ campus,” Link Principal Justin Jones said in a statement. “And so, we have to make sure we’re giving them everything we can.”

Additionally, three of the four SISD schools that received A ratings are schools of choice, meaning students apply to attend those campuses, which offer specialty programming.

Compared with neighboring districts, no KISD campus received less than a C—or acceptable performance—and only one CFISD campus received a D—or in need of improvement.

At the same time, 5% of Aldine ISD campuses and 7.7% of Houston ISD campuses received F’s. While education officials across the state claimed the new accountability system favored rich districts when the system was first implemented, both Aldine and Houston ISDs had higher percentages of economically disadvantaged students in 2018-19 than SISD.

However, each of SISD’s F-rated campuses had a higher percentage of economically disadvantaged students than the state average of 60.6%. in 2018-19.

Plans for improvement

Campuses that receive a D or F rating have to produce and implement a targeted improvement plan, Cobb said. F-rated campuses also have to submit those plans to the TEA for review and monitoring and are required to have an effective school framework consultant to assist campus officials with ensuring they are implementing effective school framework strategies.

Cobb said F-rated campuses that do not show improvement will have additional TEA monitoring that increases with additional years of failure.

While all D- and F-rated campuses in SISD have already submitted and had their targeted improvement plans approved by the board of trustees, Cobb said the district has been working to improve its middle school level long before receiving the 2018-19 ratings through its Lift 6 initiative, which aims to improve SISD middle schools, of which five campuses received F’s. The program began with a listening tour by Watson in 2018-19, and the Lift 6 initiative was implemented in August.

SISD Director of Communications Karen Garrison said the initiative uses best practices from successful schools nationwide, many of which align with effective school framework strategies.

“We understand that middle school can be a difficult transition for students,” Garrison said. “We’re now doing more to support both our students and staff to create a learning environment that is designed for young adolescents.”

At the Oct. 8 SISD board of trustees meeting, the board also approved $4.2 million in middle school investments, including $2.5 million to reduce the middle school student-to-teacher ratio from 30-1 to 28-1, as well as funding to purchase new desks, expand parent-engagement efforts, increase substitute teacher pay and explore specialty programming. Additionally, Garrison said the district now has two assistant superintendents dedicated solely to supporting staff at the middle school level.

Chief Academic Officer Linda Macias likewise said CFISD has implemented similar strategies at Bane Elementary School—the one campus that received a D rating. Those strategies include smaller class sizes and extended instructional day for some students.

While KISD is not working to improve any D- or F-rated campuses, Superintendent Jenny McGown said the district is tackling the Closing the Gaps domain—which is one of the factors that goes into a district or campus’s overall accountability rating. The domain looks at how well different groups of students, such as those who are of a certain race or income level, are performing.

System shortcomings

As the TEA’s A-F system is still in its infancy, school district officials said they believe the system as it is structured leaves room for improvement.

According to the TEA, 70% of the accountability rating is based on Student Achievement, which measures performance on state assessments, and/or School Progress, which shows campus improvement year over year. The remaining 30% is based on Closing the Gaps, which reflects gains among economically disadvantaged students—of which SISD had 70.1% in 2018-19.

“A greater emphasis on equity will make the accountability rating system more reflective of how schools and districts are doing,” Garrison said.

Macias likewise said CFISD officials believe the ratings rely too heavily on the results of the State of Texas Assessments of Academic Readiness tests.

“As long as the accountability system is heavily dependent on STAAR data ... the great accomplishments of our students are not accurately reflected by a single letter grade,” Macias said.
By Hannah Zedaker
Born and raised in Cypress, Texas, Hannah Zedaker graduated from Sam Houston State University in 2016 with a bachelor's degree in mass communication and a minor in political science. She began as an intern with Community Impact Newspaper in 2015 and was hired upon graduation as a reporter for The Woodlands edition in May 2016. In January 2019, she was promoted to serve as the editor of the Spring/Klein edition where she covers Spring ISD and Harris County Commissioners Court, in addition to business, development and transportation news.


Tenants in Houston and Harris County can apply for a second round of rent relief in Mid-August. (Courtesy Visit Houston)
Rent relief: How to apply for the latest assistance in Houston and Harris County

Renters can apply for a new round of rental assistance in mid-August.

Teachers with Cy-Fair ISD spoke out against in-person professional development days at an Aug. 10 school board meeting. (Courtesy American Federation of Teachers Cy-Fair branch)
UPDATE: Teachers’ union granted temporary restraining order in lawsuit against Cy-Fair ISD

The lawsuit was filed the same day a three-week slate of in-person professional development kicked off for CFISD teachers.

Dr. Molly Lopez is the director of the Texas Institute for Excellence in Mental Health and also serves as a research associate professor at the Steve Hicks School of Social Work at The University of Texas at Austin. (Designed by Stephanie Torres/Community Impact Newspaper)
Q&A: Mental health expert talks emotional well-being, building resiliency for the 2020-21 school year

According to Dr. Molly Lopez, director of the Texas Institute for Excellence in Mental Health, the upcoming school year will serve as an opportunity for students, families, teachers and school administrators to learn skills in coping, re-evaulate mental health protocols and build resiliency in challenging times.

(Community Impact Newspaper staff)
Texas Medical Center: COVID-19 hospitalizations down 19% since Aug. 7

Hospitals with the medical center reported fewer COVID-19 patients, fewer in intensive care and fewer deaths than last week.

Jules Design Bar
TABC change opens window for some bars to qualify as restaurants under state pandemic orders

Following a new industry guideline recently distributed by the Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission, more bars across the state may soon be able to qualify as restaurants.

Sixteen long-term flood mitigation project recommendations throughout the San Jacinto River watershed were presented at a public meeting Aug. 13. (Community Impact staff)
16 projects totaling $2.9B-$3.3B could help prevent flooding in San Jacinto River watershed

The proposals are designed to reduce flood damage projected to occur throughout the San Jacinto River watershed over the coming 50 years

Aug. 13 marked the fourth day in a row in which the daily case count was under 1,000, an occurrence that took place only twice between July 15 and Aug. 9. (Community Impact staff)
Harris County coronavirus count: 931 new cases, 34 deaths confirmed Aug. 13

Aug. 13 marked the fourth day in a row in which the daily case count was under 1,000, an occurrence that took place only twice between July 15 and Aug. 9.

Daily festival capacity will be limited to 22,500, according to festival information for the upcoming 46th season. (Courtesy Steven David Photography)
Mask-break areas, limited capacity: Texas Renaissance Festival unveils health guidelines for 46th season

All tickets for the upcoming 46th festival season are date-specific, and no general admission tickets will be sold at the gate.

Safety measures planned to combat COVID-19 spread in Cy-Fair ISD

According to the district, 34% of students plan to attend classes in person, while 43% intend to engage virtually.

The Harris County Annex off Cypresswood Drive is among the buildings that reopened Aug. 10 to offer several services by appointment, including marriage licenses. (Staff photo)
Harris County Clerk's Office reopens annex buildings for services by appointment

Residents can now arrange to get marriage licenses, birth and death certificates and Doing Business As filings at 11 annex buildings located throughout the county.

Dr. Peter Hotez and Dr. Maria Elena Bottazzi are co-leading the research team developing a coronavirus vaccine, which now has a licensing agreement with India-based company Biological E. Limited. (Courtesy Baylor College of Medicine)
Baylor College of Medicine announces licensing agreement for COVID-19 vaccine candidate

India has reported nearly 2.4 million total COVID-19 cases since the pandemic reached its borders.

The new four-floor, 83-room hotel is located within close proximity to George Bush Intercontinental Airport and offers a complimentary airport shuttle. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Holiday Inn Express & Suites now open on FM 1960

The new four-floor, 83-room hotel is located within close proximity to George Bush Intercontinental Airport and offers a complimentary airport shuttle.